Deflated
In Schuyler’s Monster, I wrote about how special needs parents step into the fray, even when we’re basically unarmed, even when we’ve found ourselves in that battle a million times before, and even when we know we’re going to lose.
“You never give up, and you persevere, not because you’re plucky or heroic or even smart, but rather because you hate the thought that there might have been some answer or solution waiting right around the next corner, and you would miss it if you gave up too early. It’s hope, and it’s stubborn and sometimes it’s even stupid, but it’s the thing you’ve got so you run with it. You go into battle against the monster with a rubber sword because, really, what else are you going to do?”
But sometimes, often even when things don’t even seem to be all that bad, we just stop. We freeze in our tracks, and we just sit down. The only word I can think of is deflated.
We heard from one of Schuyler’s teachers on Friday, asking for our help. Some kids in her class had reported that Schuyler was hitting them, out of what the teacher theorized was high spirits. Could we talk to her and see that it didn’t happen again?
Shamefully, we didn’t react the way we should have. We confronted Schuyler about it shortly after, once we were away from the school, and we did so from a place of disappointment and accusation. If there’s one thing I would take back this past week, it would be how I reacted to Schuyler, and to her teacher, for that matter.
It was only when Schuyler gave her side of the story, in which she had gotten physical with these boys not because she’s a high-spirited whack-a-doo weird kid or whatever, but because she was frustrated, and she was hurt. She’d heard them talking about her, and when she confronted them, they told her she didn’t belong in the class, that she wasn’t skilled enough and shouldn’t have been there at all. Angry and on the spot, she lashed out inappropriately, and it was that part that the other kids reported to the teacher, who didn’t even bother to find out what her side of the story might be.
It was a classic example of how kids like Schuyler get marginalized, and in this particular case, her own parents actually participated, shamefully. Schuyler had no agency here. She wasn’t a fully-realized human being with a perspective and a story to tell. She was a problem, one that her parents needed to solve. She wasn’t in trouble, exactly, because she can’t help herself, right? She can’t be expected to be held to the same standards as other students.
Except she can. I think she’s waiting for someone to take her seriously.
There’s not much to say about what came next, because it’s still a work in progress. Schuyler wrote a note of apology in which she took responsibility for her actions and also explained what happened, all in her own words without assistance. She’s still waiting for some acknowledgement or response, as are we. Four days later, it’s becoming clear that we’re probably going to have to push for things to be made right.
And I have to be honest. I feel completely emotionally depleted. We all had a rough weekend, with the death of a family dog we’ve had for nine years, and so that has admittedly not helped. But honestly, I was feeling this on Friday, too. That sense of having been here before, of having already argued for Schuyler’s right to be human. Sometimes it feels like two steps forward and one step back, but honestly, other times it just feels like walking in circles.
Today, I’m tired of the walking. I’m tired of screwing up, and I’m tired of other people treating Schuyler like a cute little pet who might pee on the carpet, rather than a complicated and nuanced human being. My weapon is a rubber sword today, and it feels especially ineffective. I’m just going to sit for a while and see what happens. I wish I had something in my tank, and I’m sure I will tomorrow.
But not today. Sorry.
Note: To support the site we make money on some products, product categories and services that we talk about on this website through affiliate relationships with the merchants in question. We get a small commission on sales of those products.That in no way affects our opinions of those products and services.
Ugh…kids that have challenges communicating make great targets for bullies, and are often marginalized by teachers who don’t take or have the time to get to the root of it. I’m disappointed that the teacher hasn’t responded after four days, though.
Hold on! High School is hard and cruel. It’s the only time in Preston’s life that I actually took him out of school without him going with me to sign him out because he was so upset he was in his teachers car. It’s not easy but remember you are just a parent without an instruction book. We all make mistakes with our children. I know I have with both of mine. Good luck and be kind to yourself and Julie.
All parents of kids with special needs have found themselves in your shoes. The circumstances may have been different but the same deflated feeling.It makes my heart so sad to hear that this happened to her. I am disappointed in the teachers but must say I am not surprised. I often seen kids with communication challenges and their parents told “oh, those are good kids. They wouldn’t have done that.” But other students give a different story. Anyhow, hopeful for Schuyler, you guys, the other kids and the teachers. We are all a work in progress. And don’t be too hard on yourselves!
Hey, I’m an EA in the school system. I don’t think it’s fair to point the finger at the teacher. Teachers do the best job they can. Imagine being the “parent” or maybe a better word would be “peacekeeper” for at least the 30 children in their class. It honestly feels like having 30 children for 6 hours and they are REQUIRED to teach your children at the same time. Think about it for a few minutes…that’s an epic amount of responsibility. Are they perfect? Absolutely not! But they do a hell of a job…I’m sorry you feel so deflated…
Given my specific knowledge of this particular situation and this teacher, I’m going to have to respectfully disagree.
Being a teacher is hard. Being a kid like Schuyler is harder.
Being a child with special needs is not easy…I know. Are you a teacher? Have you ever been a teacher? Do have any idea how hard it is for a teacher to ask the parent for help these days…I’m not saying that this was the case for this situation….I’m saying put yourself in BOTH the teachers shoes AND Schuyler shoes.
I agree with Rob – the teacher’s responsibility is to get both sides of the story before heading to the parents. The fact that the teacher jumped to an erroneous conclusion speaks to the teacher’s assumptions about Schuyler’s agency in this. Teaching is a tough job – but being a kid like Rob’s kid, or my kid, or many many others is harder. Acceptance and the benefit of the doubt are in order. Rob, if it makes you feel any better (and I’m sure it won’t because, hey misery loves company) I had a similar reaction to my son when his bully caused some outrageous behaviour on his part – really grim, upsetting and disturbing… and I blamed him before I had any idea about the extent of the bullying! It was only after I calmed down enough to re-interview my boy in a quiet kitchen at home, at night away from everything else, did he divulge what had been happening at recess for several months. In this case, thankfully, the school reacted appropriately (not that I gave them a choice exactly…as I am not known for subtlety in these matters). It was many years ago now but it rattled me to my core…and plus, I am so sorry for what happened to Schuyler – no one should have to hear that from their peers at school – it is cruel and completely unacceptable. The teacher should definitely run some kind of an intervention on this. Inclusive education is work – so it the work needs to actually be done in order for it to work.
I read this and I’m choosing not to argue…two things though…teachers are not mind readers and teachers have amazing hearts because they sure don’t get paid well for what they do…I’m in the middle of these situations ALL THE TIME as an EA. I choose to advocate for both sides…please don’t be so quick to throw a teacher under the bus
I don’t think anyone here is throwing teachers under the bus.
Please be assured that I am totally not throwing this or any teacher under a bus! I am just disappointed that this particular teacher missed a pretty significant step in problem-solving 101. Human beings make mistakes and should ideally get critical feedback when they happen. Respectfully critiquing a teacher’s (or an EAs) performance of their duties is not throwing them under a bus. It is critical feedback that they need for next time. There is a difference. BTW, I spent the entire month of September baking for our striking teachers precisely because I support them and have a lifetime of gratitude for how hard they work to include, support and educate my son. http://www.solidaritybaking.wordpress.com. I also wrote an email in support of them to our local public radio and it was read on the air the next day. Plus my partner is an EA so yeah…no worries, I know inclusion is hard work and we are in it together.
April, I think we all understand what a teacher’s job entails and that it’s not easy. None of us thinks that it is, but it is her job. What do you think should have been done in this situation? Was just getting the story from one side and then proceeding from that point of view the right thing to do? Even if we give her a pass on not finding out what part the other students played in the incident, once she found out, it seems to me she should have talked to the parents about how she now would handle this situation and what she would do to ensure that it not happen again. It is not ok for a group to tell a student she doesn’t belong and it is not ok to hit. Both issues need to be addressed. (However, I think Schuyler’s response seems pretty typical – either lashing out or crying when someone hurts and humiliates you.) Also, do you think the teacher should talk to her class about everyone belonging? Those students who incorrectly stated that Schuyler doesn’t belong in their class heard that from someone and they need to know that that is wrong. I hope the teacher teaches that to her students. You are right, being a teacher is not easy as there’s more to education than just reading and math. I hope this teacher is up to her role and I hope she lets the parents know it.
Be a teacher for one day and you will have a glimpse of understanding…there were a lot of assumptions made in this situation. Did the teacher say she only talked to the student that Schuyler lashed out at? The tax her didn’t ask Schuyler what had happened or are we assuming that they didn’t?
April, there were zero assumptions made in this situation, but you make an interesting point. Why would I need to ask the teacher if she spoke to Schuyler? Why wouldn’t Schuyler be the one to ask? Why would we give the teacher total agency but none for Schuyler? (Spoiler: that’s actually how it usually goes for kids with intellectual disabilities.)
For the record, as I believe I said, the teacher did not talk to Schuyler, but instead asked us to talk to her.
And I taught for many, many years in public school music programs. Since you keep assuming I have no idea what teachers go through.
You’re right…the teacher was all wrong…and all teachers do their best to just get one side of the story…but just remember there is always a why to the what…have you asked the teacher?
I skirt the outer edge of special needs parenting, but with my sensory child growing older I am getting deeper into the fray. This is a topic that drives me nuts!! These things rarely happen in a vacuum, even with special needs parenting. It’s ok, I have done it too, accused my child without finding the answer, it sucks but we are human. Hug to you and a big ‘right on’ to Schuyler for confronting them even if the outcome wasn’t perfect, I admire her. and Shame on the teacher, this is her profession why wouldn’t she look into further? After my friends neuro typical son complained to her about a friends daughter hitting him on head with a ski pole. She said (and I will always admire) ‘It’s my experience people don’t go around hitting people on the head with ski poles without some reason.’ Not that violence is the answer but just saying…..
Boy did I open a can of worms. I think we as teachers (EA’s) play mediator after EVERY recess with probably 5-10 children…when they would rather be teaching. Did you ask Schuyler if the teacher asked her side of the story? And IF the teacher didn’t ask her side of the story…have you asked the teacher why she didn’t? As I have mentioned before teachers aren’t perfect. In fact, a LOT of teachers are overworked and under a lot of pressure with up to 35 kids in their class…I am disappointed that you wrote a blog essentially “blaming” the teacher for your child’s behaviour…the teacher asked you to help…the behaviour whether or not warranted or not was not the right response. Yes, children with special needs don’t always know how to respond and they do “lash” out or hit….but it still doesn’t make it ok. Again I work with special needs children all day (which I love) but I too would have asked the parent of the child who hit to help me see that that doesn’t happen again. Also, to be honest, I wouldn’t discuss with one parent the consequence of the other child. Meaning I would tell the boy that made those extremely inappropriate comments what Schuyler’s consequence would be…I hope that made sense. I deal with parents and children individually….
With respect, I kind of hope you don’t teach comprehensive reading. All your questions have been answered, most of them in the post itself. I think you’re knee-jerk responding to what you perceive as an attack on the noble profession of teaching, without actually reading what I’ve said, or what others have said, either. I’m not sure I can help you any further.
Thank you for your comment on my writing skills…I intentionally answered my own questions :)…I read what you wrote and I read that you blamed the teacher for making you a bad parent. I am not saying that you are a bad parent. I am saying thats what you essentially wrote.”Shamefully, we didn’t react the way we should have.”..you blamed the teacher for not telling you the whole story…
Parents need to take responsibility for their child’s actions…special needs or not…and ultimately teach their children to take responsibility for their own actions…whether justified or not…it the job of the teacher to teach.
I am done now…I won’t be commenting anymore
NOTE: I just deleted a comment, not because I disagreed with it, but because if I wanted to publicly identify the class and teacher in this post, I would have done so. That wasn’t the point.
As to whether the boys in the class might have been right about Schuyler not belonging in this particular class, I suppose that could be true, although that’s a pretty sad version of inclusion. It’s not an advanced placement, college prep class. It’s an elective class, one for which she has met all the prerequisites, and one in which she is making an A. Does that mean she’s at the same level as her classmates? Of course not. But in the past, she’s succeeded with a modified curriculum, and that plan hasn’t changed, at least on IEP paper.
It may very well turn out that her teacher will determine she doesn’t fit. That would be wrong, in my judgement, but that is certainly his place to make that call. But she won’t be voted off the island by classmates, so in that respect, whether or not these boys were “right” is entirely irrelevant.
NOTE: Again, I deleted a comment for the exact same reason as before. If I wanted to identify the class and the teacher, I would have.
Have the classmates been approached about this? Have their parents now been notified as you were in terms of them saying inappropriate things, as Schulyler now made her apologies for reacting tho their inappropriate comments in an inappropriate way? This is one to take to the counselors. If she had been AA and such remarks had been made, it would have made for quite a furor. That she is in a minority that is being marginalized is an issue that should be addressed, and hugs to you Rob, because you have to be the one to address as her parent at this time.
Just here to say that any time a kid hits another kid, whoever’s in charge should take it seriously and find out what happened from BOTH kids. What you’re expecting from the teacher is both incredibly important for special needs kids who may already be ignored or dismissed, and, generally important for any other kid. Considering the teacher’s behaviour, and the other kids’ behaviour (regardless of their thoughts, they were cruel in how they treated Schuyler), no wonder you’re feeling exhausted. Sending lots of support to you and Schuyler from Australia 🙂
I relate to this so much, even though my girls with communication struggles are in early elementary school. This: “She wasn’t a fully-realized human being with a perspective and a story to tell. She was a problem…” happens far too often. It’s painful.
Seems to have been the “Month” this year. I have a non-spec ed, planning to retire at the end of the year, spent the first 2 months of the year running for municipal council… Teacher. One that probably thought teaching 7 kids was easy. Ironically, his back yard abuts my FSW’s. She warned him about parents like me. 🙂
One, that has forgotten what it means to be a early teen boy.
One, that cannot write an IEP but in spec ed, it’s his job not the LST’s.
In 14mths I have never once talked to the Principal. I left a long message and although he never called me, the Teacher did text (politely). The school board arrives on Thursday to deal with the IEP. Then comes the transition to highschool.
Sigh….
And yes, the TEACHER needs to talk to ALL students. No sympathy there.